Dancing Lessons from God

Sara Davidson

|

October, 24, 2018

DENVER—I was lost, searching for Helen Simon, walking through a maze of corridors in a skilled nursing community—the current term for the dreaded words, “nursing home.” I passed a dining area with no one eating. A grand piano with no one playing. Seeing an attendant, I asked, “Where can I find suite M-2—Helen Simon?” *

“She’s not in her room,” the attendant said, pointing to an alcove with a large TV and a woman in a wheelchair parked in front. “That’s her,” she said.

I dropped to my knees beside the wheelchair. “Hello, I’m Sara, I’m a doula, and your son asked me to visit you.” Her son had told me Helen has advancing Alzheimer’s and communicates mostly through facial expressions. “I heard that you love books, and your favorite author is Willa Cather?” Helen looked me in the eye, but did not respond.

Cather on Time cover, 1931

“She’s one of my favorite authors too,” I said. “Would you like me to read you one of her books?” She kept looking in my eyes, so I pulled up a chair and started reading Death Comes for the Archbishop. As I pronounced the title, I wondered if I’d picked the wrong book.

This was my first experience as an end-of-life doula, something I’d never in my wildest imagination thought I’d be.

Doula, a Greek word, is the professional title for a woman who supports a new mother through childbirth and learning to care for her baby. More recently, it’s become a title for a person who supports someone going through the dying process.

I’ve never been caregiver. My lifelong calling has been writing—stories that inform, inspire, or amuse—and I’ve had to safeguard the time and energy needed to do that. I never understood the pull people felt to what seemed more altruistic professions—nursing, counseling, social work. Last winter, though, after losing a friend, someone whose absence left a hollow in my life, I found myself in a state of angst. Darkness was visible. Omens were everywhere: the end was increasingly nigh.

During this time, I received an email from Tarron Estes, founder of the Conscious Dying Institute, inviting me to take a three-month training to become a certified end-of-life doula.

Kurt Vonnegut wrote, “Peculiar travel suggestions are dancing lessons from God.” I thought the same might apply to peculiar email invitations. I had no interest in a career as a doula, but I sensed that this was an opportunity to face my fears, to immerse myself in the practical reality of dying.

The course began with a three-day seminar, then a three-month break, during which we were told to imagine this was our last three months to live. We were to make it the “best three months,” and prepare for the way we wanted to die.

Most people, when surveyed, say they want to die at home, not in a hospital, but only a small percentage actually do. It takes foresight and effort. Working with a partner, we did research on issues like how to rent a hospital bed and how to find affordable home care. We made lists of music we wanted played and poems, literature and sacred texts we wanted read to us. We also made lists of what was important to do in our last three months, then set dates to do those things and held each other accountable. (We did most of them)

The course ended with a four-day intensive, during which, to my surprise, the fear I’d been nursing was transformed into a knowing that love doesn’t die, love goes on. I could actually envision a peaceful ending, surrounded by love, in a state of acceptance.

I knew that in years ahead, friends and relatives would be dying, and I wanted to be a companion, walk with them, not for pay but from love. I put out the word that I was available, and a friend of a friend in Boston called and asked if I would help his mother, Helen, who was in a care home in Denver. The man had a demanding job and teenage kids, so he could only make short visits to be with his mother. I said I would visit Helen soon.

As I sat beside her wheelchair, I related the prologue to Cather’s novel, which I’d read in advance to make sure it was compelling. I acted out the prologue, using a dramatic voice and big gestures, to hold her attention.

“It’s 1851,” I said, “and a young priest, Jean Latour, is lost in the New Mexico territory. He’s riding a horse and has a pack mule…” I mimed riding a horse. “…and he’s about to die of thirst.

Opening scene from Cather’s book

There’s nothing around him but scrubby red hills and juniper trees.” I made the shape of a tree with my arms. “All the red hills look the same. He can’t see a trail, can’t tell what direction he’s heading, and thinks he may be riding in circles.” Helen gave a snort. Was she drifting off?

“They’ve had nothing to eat or drink for two days. The animals are about to collapse…” I imitated a horse collapsing. “When suddenly, the priest feels the horse come alive beneath him, raising its neck and sniffing the air.”

Helen’s eyes opened. I wondered how much she was hearing, let alone understanding.

“The priest gives rein to the horse, hoping he smells water and can find it,” I said. “After an hour, they come to a rise in the desert and below them, there’s a big river…” With my arm I traced the course of a flowing stream. Her eyes followed my arm. “There’re trees and grass, and an adobe house. A young girl runs out to welcome the priest, who can’t believe his eyes,” I said. “The people living there bring him water and lead the animals to drink. They serve the priest a fine dinner and give him a feather bed to sleep in. Lying in that bed, after preparing himself to die, he wonders at the miracle that’s happened. He knows, now, that he’s meant to do his work in the new world.” I stretched my arms. “Is that interesting?”

Helen made some sounds I couldn’t understand. Then slowly, she said, “In life…. anything you try…. you take a risk.”

I was startled at her comprehension. “I bet you took risks in your life?”

She stared in my eyes. “I sure did.” She sighed. “I want to go… bed. I’m tired… Are you?” She repeated the word “tired” several times. I went looking for someone to help her back to bed.

In a separate room, I saw a staff member, Joan,* working with a group of women and one man circled in their wheelchairs. I told Joan what just happened with Helen, and that she wants to go to bed. “Not only did she grasp the core of the story, she commented on it.”

“Sounds like a great book,” Joan said. “But… that’s not Helen.”

What?

“That’s Ruth. Helen is in her room.”

I’d just spent an hour reading to the wrong woman?

Joan led me to a room at the end of a different corridor. “This is Helen.” She looked more like what I’d expected, with a crown of loose white hair, lying in bed on her back with her eyes closed. Her arms rested on top of the sheet, and one was waving about slowly. “You can talk to her,” Joan said.

I pulled up a chair next to the bed and told her I was a doula. One blue eye opened, the other stayed shut. I put my hand on her arm, stroked it gently, and took her hand. She gripped it with her own, squeezing tight.

Just sitting there, the minutes passed in a comfortable, companionable silence. Her hand relaxed, but kept holding mine. When I rose to go, I had to unfasten the two. I said goodbye, promising to come again, and walked off, feeling peaceful and, interestingly, fulfilled.

Later, I remembered what Bebe Moore Campbell, the gifted, best-selling African-American writer, had told me when I interviewed her while I was writing Leap!  She had a family member who was mentally ill, and, finding there were no mental health facilities in the black neighborhood where she lived, was working to raise awareness, eliminate the stigma of mental illness, and bring help to the community.

“We’ve been stars,” Bebe said. “Now it’s our turn to serve.”

At the time, that didn’t seem to apply to me. Now… it resonates.

* name changed for privacy

Please leave a comment. Have you thought about where and how you’d like your ending to be?

PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Sara’s Blog


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Sara Davidson. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact
  • Ken Pyburn says:

    Good piece, I have followed you and been part of the “Death OK” movement here in the Northwest for about six years now. Now in my 80’s I have my own doula, trained a little differently than you were but she recently officiated at my Rites of Passage into my ninth decade and will also officiate at my death and my Natural Burial.
    Years ago, 14 to be exact, I read and then lived Stephen Levine’s “A Year to Live”, and it changed my life forever. In some small way I have since been involved with Death Cafe’s growth here in the Northwest and they continue to grow after I stopped doing that work. Many of my freinds find my talking about my own death somewhat disquieting but like Reb Zalman who I had the pleasure of being with several times, I believe we must at this stage of our lives.

  • Lark says:

    SOOOO beautiful, Sarah.

    Thanks for writing it, and for sharing your beautiful humanity in so many ways.

  • SUZI RUDD COHEN says:

    As you know, it is not often that I am rendered speechless! But you did it! Thank you for sharing this voyage you are taking and for sharing these professional but very personal reactions that have made me stop and think about myself and family all day long.
    Keep on making a difference..you are exceptional, caring and in my opinion, genius!

  • John Patrick Grace says:

    Dancing with God – what an interesting concept. Entirely mystical. A foreshadowing of eternity, especially if you like to dance. Glad to hear of your becoming a doula, Sara. I’ve now logged seven years with my shepherd-husky mix “Cooper” as a therapy-dog minder at Hospice. So many stories. After all, Dog is God spelled backwards! Godspeed

  • Anne Turley says:

    When I turned 65 this year, Kaiser asked for my advanced directive. I became enthusiastic and wrote about what kind of memorial I would like to have and wrote down all the phone numbers of people to call, if they are still alive. I chose the daughter of a life-long friend to be my decision maker, should it come to that. There is a Facebook Group called Elder Orphans, where people discuss to whom to leave power of attorney and things like that, since we have no children or other living relatives younger than us.

    I chose the music I would like and the kind of party I would like it to be. It was really up lifting. And then, I had a long talk with my friend’s daughter and that was fun, too.

    Since my father died when I was 36, and we had planned a cruise to Alaska, but he didn’t get to take it, I realized I’d better do the things I wanted to in life before I was too old to enjoy them. So I went on an African Safari, dived the Great Barrier Reef, River Rafted down the Grand Canyon, rode a bicycle along the Rhone River in the south of France from Chateau to Chateau.

    I also realized one of the most important things to me was my relationships. It is my friends who have literally saved my life over the years. So I strive for honesty and transparency, try to curb myself when I become passive aggressive or resentful. Gratitude is a great antidote to resentment, as someone else pointed out.

    And to me, life is not worth living without a sense of wonder. Butterflies, hummingbirds, the feeling of an ocean wave breaking over your body. Marvelous. And the ability to laugh. Laughter is a great healer.

    I had to learn that my worth was not defined by my “cool” job in the media, but by the way in which I treat people. Whoo, self image was a really big one for me, very painful.

    Life is a journey and the only thing I am sure of is that I am not sure of anything.

  • Dr. Barbra Rubin says:

    beautiful,Sara!

    yes, I have. I have established a Living Trust for my 3 children and my daughter and I discuss from time to time,how it will be towards my end.

  • Robert Lang says:

    “Dancing Lesson’s From God” is a beautiful post. Your reading of Cather’s novel to Ruth may have seemed like a mistake, but I believe there are no coincidences in life and death. I think that maybe you were to be there for Ruth too.
    I have been a caregiver for many people. I was enrolled in a Master’s Degree of Spirituality when my Mother went through the final stage of Alzheimer’s disease. As part of my degree, we had to go through a mortuary where they prepare bodies for burial. What actually killed my mom was a massive stroke, but she held on for three agonizing days. Finally, I told her it was ok for her to let go. I went home and got some sleep with my father, mom died that night. I still miss her, but I knew I was not helping her holding on, and she was clinging onto life for her family.
    Thank you for writing this piece for all Alzheimer’s Patients who deserve dignity and not to be forgotten.

  • John Jones says:

    This evening I read your “Dancing Lessons from God” piece. I found it completely authentic and completely kind, and wanted to tell you that.

    I myself have had some experience with very aged loved ones and friends, some with the respective health conditions and living situations of “Helen” and “Ruth,” and I have no doubt whatsoever that your visits to them reached them and ministered to them in a significant way. Perhaps, somehow, their spirits had a way of storing the love and caring I’m sure they felt from you, for the times they were alone.

    You are Jewish, I am Christian. My sense of what happened in the “nursing community” you visited was that God led you first to Ruth, to touch her in the exactly appropriate way she needed and could accept and respond to, and then to Helen, to touch her in the exactly appropriate way she needed and could receive. In my view, the gift was both to them and to you, and I suspect that you experienced it that way as well.

  • Mark Battat says:

    Thanks so much for sharing Sara. My Grandmother lived to 105 and died in 2012.She was a sweetheart. Sophisticated and smart as a whip and everyone who met her adored her. When she turned 101 she started to lose her short term memory but her long term memory was intact from around 1907 to 1990. We always had dinner together on Monday nights so I’d study up on something from her lifetime that was historic and all of a sudden her brain would go into overdrive and off she’d go.

    There’s a lot to learn from our older generation and a visit like yours – words or wordless – can make an enormous difference.

  • Jean (Krasnansky) Thompson says:

    My mom at 94 was scheduled to leacpve Hopkins hospital after a stroke, a shooter they called it. She recovered fully with mild swallowing issues. On Tuesday night I was with her as I’d been nearly most of the previous five days. The year before I’d put together photos of the family over the many years. Her and my dad and us six kids as children and grown into adulthood. I included a few poems I’d written and used Shutterfly to make it into a book. I’d sent it to her for her birthday with an extra copy made for myself. I’d brought that one with me. When the meal came, the entree didn’t seem very appetizing, so I suggested to my mom that she just have the puddings and desserts. Afterward, I asked if she’d like to look at the book and she did, her eyes, she said we’re tired from reading the novel she’d checked out of the library. We sat together and went page by page. My mom’s crooked fingers but not painful touched the pictures. Me at six in my school uniform, her sisters who’d died before her, her youngest, the twin boys, dressed identically, her Italian mom and dad posed in a photo of yore. She in a long dress, he in his WWI uniform. We came across a picture of my mom as a wasp waisted woman of 20. A beauty with dark curly hair and a loving smile she never lost. My mom had six children, five boys, and me, the wayward, daughter, the only without children. I have photo albums full of the pictures of my life, friends and family. And I may do a life review as such like it spontaneously occurred that evening with my mom and the family photo book I made for her. She died the next day at 4:30pm after a rousing few games of scrabble with my brother, she was glowing, her favorite game. I’d stopped in to drop off yarn and crochet needles for her then went off to have lunch with an old friend. I missed her passing by 10 minutes. I dashed up the stairs to her room. She looked beautiful. I couldn’t stop looking at her. So what does this have to do with how I want to die? How I want to die is how my mom lived. She was happy, content, smiled all the time, ready to laugh at a good joke, a deep listener, not to mention she let me eat the raw cookie dough when making chocolate chip,oatmeal cookies, she was kind to all. A gentlemen once came to the door, it was summer, I walked behind her to answer it. She looked at him, nodded, went to the kitchen and brought him out a sandwich and he left. My mom had peace in her heart and prayers for all. She knew life could be very hard for some folks and that the world with wars and fighting wasn’t such a great place, but she never stopped giving and smiling. In my youth, she wasn’t a huggy kissy mom, something I yearned for and I would leaned against her and stay in her orbit for that comfort, but she was a dependable sanctuary of stability and peace and laughter.. Who needed church when your mom hums and smiles all the day long.