Channeling Bob Dylan

Sara Davidson

|

January, 3, 2025

I was curious and wary of seeing the new movie about Bob Dylan, “A Complete Unknown.” Dylan is still alive and well, presumably, and I thought it would be near impossible for an actor to conjure up Dylan’s look, posture, and inimitable way of singing.

At first, the actor, Timothy Chalamet, looks miscast and self-conscious as Dylan, but this works for him as he steadily begins to take on the facial expressions and posture of the peculiar, driven young man who arrives in New York city in 1961, age 19, determined to make it as a “folk singer.”

Watching it took me back to 1964, when I was sharing a scrappy apartment in Berkeley with three other young women students. One of them, Pris, went to see Joan Baez at the Berkeley Community Theater and came back raving about Joan and the young man whom she’d brought on stage to sing with her, a guy called Bob Dylan.

Pris described how Joan and Bob had leaned their heads toward each other, almost touching, as they sang into twin mikes.

Pris was my favorite friend, since we’d been assigned to share a room in a sorority at Berkeley. She had a great presence, made everyone laugh, and was the person people sought out when they needed to “talk.” Pris spoke in superlatives, like, “The greatest artist in the world!” and “The most charming man I have ever met!” She was voted the “peppiest pledge” in the sorority, and she made me feel loved.

There was no Internet then and we didn’t have computers. (can you remember/imagine?) So the day after seeing Bob Dylan, Pris pulled me to the record store on Telegraph Ave. to buy his album, The Free Wheelin’ Bob Dylan.  In less than a week, we knew the songs by heart.

We stared at the cover, where Dylan is walking toward us, snuggled up with a girl who has hair like most of us did then—long and straight. They’re walking toward the camera in the center of a cobblestone street in Greenwich Village, and we wondered if she was a model or Dylan’s girlfriend and what she was like.

I moved from Berkeley to New York the next year to go to the Columbia School of Journalism, and Pris got married to her friend since childhood, Tony. They moved to London and I rarely saw them again. But I continued buying Dylan’s records—“Highway 61 Revisited” and “Blonde on Blonde.” The albums that followed, however, did not move me and I stopped listening much to him after that.

Until 1975, when I was living in Venice, Ca, working on my first book, Loose Change. The guy I was seeing, also named Bobby, brought over Dylan’s latest, “Blood on the Tracks,” and we were taken by the song, “Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts.” We listened to it again and again to unravel the story Dylan was singing about: a bank robber called the “Jack of Hearts,” and two women who loved him, Lily and Rosemary, the latter of whom ended up being hanged for murdering the Jack of Hearts with a penknife.

We decided to act out the song, and rented period dresses and authentic cowboy clothing from Western Costume in Hollywood, which had been the primo costume supplier for movies and T.V. since 1913. One of our friends, a photographer, volunteered to take pictures of us in character.

We researched hair styles from the old West, and began scouting to find a place that looked like an old saloon. We learned the song by heart, and excitement was mounting, when suddenly our friend Bobby had a motorcycle accident and had to have surgery, and the energy for us to stage the Jack of Hearts fizzled out.

But I always loved the song.

In the years and decades that followed, Dylan’s singing voice changed, and I was not enamored by his new music. Then, last week, when I watched A Complete Unknown, I was smiling all through it, wondering how much of it was true.

My guy, Rio, refused to watch it because Dylan had been a major influence when he was growing up and he didn’t want to see a Hollywood version. But I must say that I felt delighted watching it, and very shortly, I wasn’t comparing Chalamet’s appearance with Dylan’s, although I did wonder if some of the events portrayed were accurate. I was transported back to that magical period we lived through, and I felt happy.

If Dylan’s music is part of your history and perhaps even if not, I suggest you may enjoy A Complete Unknown.

Let me know, please.

PLEASE LEAVE A COMMENT

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Subscribe to Sara’s Blog


By submitting this form, you are consenting to receive marketing emails from: Sara Davidson. You can revoke your consent to receive emails at any time by using the SafeUnsubscribe® link, found at the bottom of every email. Emails are serviced by Constant Contact
  • Patrick Langston says:

    Hi Sara. As a journalist who has cringed upon having his own share of blunders pointed out, I hate to draw your attention to the one you made in the above post. However, the error should be corrected. You’ve confused the cover of The Times They Are A-Changin’, which features a skeptical, rather pouty Dylan, with that of The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan, which has that wonderful photo of Dylan and his then-girlfriend Susan Rotolo on a wintery New York street.
    BTW, in case you missed it, you’ll find a terrific cover of Lily, Rosemary and the Jack of Hearts on Tom Russell’s 2004 album, Indians Cowboys Horses and Dogs, with Russell, Eliza Gilkyson and Joe Ely sharing the vocals.
    Best wishes for 2025.
    Patrick Langston, Ottawa, Ontario

    • oh Patrick, I’m so embarrassed. Thank you for pointing it out, though i can’t do much about it now. The blog was sent out to about 4,000 people, and I can’t suck it back in. I’m a big fan of Tom Russell, but don’t remember him covering that song. Hope our paths may cross at some time. Sara

  • Susan Jones says:

    Thank you for this! So timely as I am going to see it today. I too was in college at the same time (at UCSB) and I bought all of his records (no CDs then). And wonder of wonders, Bob and I have the same birthday! May 24. And I loved Loose Change.

  • Arielle Ford says:

    I’ve never been a Dylan fan, his voice is like nails on a chalkboard to me, and his music, is just not my thing. However, myb husband is a superfaan and I went to see the film with him. I LOVE THE FILM. Still don’t love the music but totally enjoyable story. I would have titled the film: “An Unlovable Genius.” Sara, I always enjoy your blogs!

  • Jacob Joseph Shefa says:

    Thank you for the lovely reminiscence of that ‘ancient time.’ It’s amazing how deeply Dylan’s unfolding is braided through our generation’s (I’m 70) trajectory. Thanks. BTW, the album cover you describe in this blog was actually “The Freewheeling Bob Dylan.” “The Time They Are A Changing” was his next, third album, and it featured a picture of Dylan looking (once again) like a very young old man (or vice-versa!). P.S. I loved your book on Reb Zalman, and have read it three times!

  • MICHAEL ZIMMERMAN says:

    I was a jazz fan when BD emerged and was swept away by Ornette Coleman’s “The Shape of Jazz To Come.”

  • Gail Storey says:

    Thanks, Sara, I loved A Complete Unknown too. I was astounded, though, by how much it helped me understand the context in which we were coming of age in the late sixties, early seventies. I had lived in Greenwich Village, so loved revisiting those streets, and soon after in a 2-room apartment (scrappy doesn’t begin to describe it) in Chicago’s Old Town where R&B was blowing up folk music. I didn’t fully realize it at the time, since I was struggling just to survive, but Bob Dylan’s rebellion helped see what a pivotal change in our country’s zeitgeist that proved to be.

  • Norma Levy says:

    I most certainly will stream it. And I’m so looking forward to it because of times it will return me to. Most reviews say it’s excellent, and it almost seems impossible for it not to give me the bittersweet feels of nostalgic pining for my younger self.

    • yes, I do think you’ll enjoy it, and I think it’s okay to be nostalgia about our youth. it gets farther away all the time, and it’s fun to be taken back for a bit.. Warmest, Sara

  • Gary Jennings says:

    Dylan is on of the reasons I’m playing the guitar today. I figured if people could endure Dylan’s singing they could endure mine.

  • Ken Halliburton says:

    I went to UCB 1964-68, Daily Cal editor, FSM, 4 years in co-op, lifetime UCB alumni member, high school Lincoln 1964 in San Francisco. Dylan stole much of his songs, which defined the 60s Berkeley. Don’t Look Back is a film of the actual Dylan, treating Joan Baez badly. He juggled multiple women, used them badly. Joan made Dylan a star. Folk music disappeared, after the British Invasion, and US folk-rock led to R&B rock copies by white males. Dylan was in part responsible, since his goal was the half a billion $ net worth he has today.
    I have a much longer description of these issues, and others. I own your book. I’m writing one myself. A Complete Unknown is hagiographic. Don’t Look Back 1965 is truth.

    • Thanks for your comments, Ken. I worked on the Daily Cal also, just before you arrived, I guess. I appreciate your point of view, but I do think his music was original, inconsistent, but when he rang the bell, it was, at least to me, gold. Warm regards, Sara

  • Barbara Stern says:

    I too enjoyed the movie knowing that Hollywood would put its stamp on it in ways to make the movie flow, even with inaccuracies, it is a movie. Over the many years and evolvement in his music, I thought the acting believeable and spoke to the changes of the era. Growing up in NYC and listening to so much inventive music formed me in many ways. The movie is more than worthwhile to see, it is also important to acknowledge where we came from to today.

  • Leland says:

    Sara. I have been reluctant to see the movie, thinking Hollywood would mess up a very precious memory of those times. It’s hard to overstate how much Dylan and Joan Baez meant in those days, the yearning, the longing for something other than our stupid lives. Anyway, thanks for the review, maybe I will see it after all.

    • Do see it, you could walk out, but I very much doubt you will. Dylan was quite involved in the production, and very quickly, I just tuned into the music and had a great time. Let me know if you do see it, what you think. Warmest, Sara

  • Mickey Lemle says:

    His songs are in our DNA.

  • Douglas Wisoff says:

    Hi Sara, I was listening to KGNU the other morning after seeing the Dylan movie and the DJ was swooning over the movie and mentioned that Dylan had his hands in all aspects of the movie production and that the only part that he wanted to edit was using the girlfriends name. So I assumed the movie was quite authentic. However I don’t care to think of Johnny Cash as he is portrayed in the movie, but maybe thats where he was at in those days.

  • Michael Reshetnik says:

    Hi, Sara. I was a New York teenage kid in the youth division of the ’60s folk explosion when Dylan came out with his first album. For a long while my parents put up with my playing that record many a time, learning the songs, moving on to the second album, The Freewheelin’ Bob Dylan. Then I was away at college, still in NY, still playing and singing folk music. I left Dylan’s music behind over the years, as it sounds like you did, but still get a throb or a kick out of the earlier stuff. Some, maybe many, of the details of Dylan’s history and milieu are altered in the movie, but the grit is there. the emotional impact of his trajectory on the people who knew him is well portrayed, the characters I recognize are believable. He was my hero for a while, back in high school, and I got a kick out of this blast from the past. Thanks for sharing!

  • Donna Greenberg says:

    Sara, I enjoyed reading your reminiscences about Dylan. I saw the film last week and was so overcome that I was in tears by the end. I didn’t expect that. It triggered a lot of nostalgia for the years I lived in NYC — only a few years after Dylan arrived. I went to all the clubs in the Village and the Fillmore East. It was a magical time that I’ve never forgotten. Dylan’s music was a huge part of that time, for me. I thought the film was superb. The acting, singing, and script really captivated me. Like you, I was a bit skeptical about how the era and Dylan would be portrayed. I think they succeeded. By the way, I’ve been reading the book that the movie was based on, “When Dylan Went Electric,” by Elijah Ward. I highly recommend it. I’m learning something new on every page!

  • Alicia Bay Laurel says:

    Just one Bob Dylan concert changed my life, no hyperbole

  • Alicia Bay Laurel says:

    I attended a Bob Dylan concert at Santa Monica Civic Auditorium as part of a group of young teens in 1963, just after his second album, Freewheelin’, came out (the one with Dylan and Suze Rotolo walking on the street on the cover). The theatre was only half full, and that half was the cheaper seats in the back. My friends had heard of him because he was, like us, a member of Habonim Labor Zionist Youth, so we came to show our support and solidarity with him. My friends pronounced his name “Die-lan”.

    I had been studying classical piano for seven years at that point, and thereby learned music theory and developed separate ten-finger control, but I had never expressed any of my thoughts or feelings through this music – only my love for the vibration of the piano itself. Listening to Bob Dylan, a skinny guy alone on stage with a harmonica on holder and a guitar, sing powerful social justice songs with his un-pretty, non-contrived voice, opened my mind to the idea of making music as a vehicle of personal and political self-expression. 

I quit piano lessons and began learning to play guitar. I soon began writing songs, including one about the murders in Mississippi of civil rights activists Schwerner, Chaney and Goodman. I studied vocal technique and guitar with a variety of teachers over several decades before going professional in my 30s. During my 50s and 60s I recorded 8 albums, toured in Japan 12 times, toured the USA for nearly a year, did some shows in Spain and licensed some of my recordings for film soundtracks. I headlined at a peace music festival during the 70th commemoration of the atomic bombing in Hiroshima at ground zero in 2015. There are YouTubes of my shows. 



    I had literally become a different person the one evening I watched and listened to young, complete unknown, Bob Dylan in concert.

    • Great to hear from you, Alicia, and about your fabulous career in music. If I hadn’t been destined to write since childhood, my second passion was music, which I never really pursued except singing occasionally with family and friends. Where do you live now? I’m in Boulder, CO. Warmest, Sara

  • Art says:

    Enjoyed your thoughts on the Unknown and on Bob. I think history tends to be tainted by the teller especially by the individual who lived it. James Taylor was my fav and the only artist that stuck to me through time. Really tough times. So maybe where you are influence what they are for you. Maybe.

  • Tina says:

    Perplexity says, “ The events portrayed in A Complete Unknown, the Bob Dylan biopic, are a blend of fact and fiction. While many moments, such as Dylan’s rise to fame and his correspondence with Johnny Cash, are based on real events, the film takes creative liberties, altering timelines and inventing some scenarios. Even Dylan, as an executive producer, contributed to fictionalizing parts of the story, emphasizing its interpretive nature rather than strict historical accuracy.”

  • CYNTHIA D'VINCENT says:

    Hi there Sara – I was with Rio until I read this. Fraught times, full of memories. Thank you, I think I’ll give it a try after all.